Main

A Video of Teenagers and a Native American Man Went Viral. Here’s What Happened. | NYT News

A close look at the videos that have emerged paints a more complete picture of what happened on Jan. 18 — and how an unlikely convergence of Americans became such a firestorm. Subscribe: http://bit.ly/U8Ys7n More from The New York Times Video: http://nytimes.com/video ---------- Whether it's reporting on conflicts abroad and political divisions at home, or covering the latest style trends and scientific developments, New York Times video journalists provide a revealing and unforgettable view of the world. It's all the news that's fit to watch.

The New York Times

5 years ago

[drumming] This image of a teen staring down a Native American man went viral. Additional videos posted online — and obtained by The Times — help show what happened. On Friday, Jan. 18, a group participating in the Indigenous Peoples March gathered at the Lincoln Memorial in Washington. In this footage, we see Nathan Phillips, the Native American man who is seen drumming in the clip that spread online. Here, he was standing after the march had concluded. “You are the children of Israel!” “That's
right.” Nearby, five men, who identify as Hebrew Israelites, are preaching. They are shouting inflammatory and derogatory comments at the Native Americans — [inaudible] [expletives] “You worship the creations and not the creator.” — and at others passing by. “Why are you being an [expletive]?” “I'm not being an [expletive]. You're —” “You're being an — You’re getting too close. You’re being an [expletive].” “You’re getting too close.” “You’re spreading hate. “You’re spreading hate. You’re sprea
ding hate. You’re spreading hate.” Meanwhile, a group of high school students is also gathering at the Lincoln Memorial. It was their meeting spot after attending the March for Life, an annual anti-abortion rally. Then the group of self-described Hebrew Israelites start to shout at the students. “A bunch of incest babies! A bunch of babies made out of incest!” The students, many of whom are wearing “Make America Great Again” apparel, start yelling and chanting back at them. [Boooooo] [shouting]
One takes off his shirt. [chanting] “A bunch of Donald Trump incest children.” [shouting continues] [drumming] At this point, we see Phillips approaching the students playing a ceremonial drum. [drumming] He later said he was trying to defuse the situation between both groups. [shouting] [drumming continues] He walks to the middle of the crowd. Some students make the tomahawk chop, a gesture that’s considered offensive. Now here’s Nicholas Sandmann, the teen also caught in the viral video. [drum
ming continues] [chanting] Phillips and Sandmann stand in front of each other for several minutes. [crowd shouting] [drumming] There is yet another back and forth, this time with a Native American activist and the students. [inaudible] “So you want to make America great because for you white people — go back to Europe where you came from.” “Because we —” “This is not your land.” “Yes, it is.” “No, it's not.” The whole interaction between Phillips and the students lasts for about 10 minutes. By
now the crowd has dispersed. Sandmann gestures to a friend, and moments later, he steps out. [drumming] [shouting] Phillips tries to talk to the crowd. “Relatives! Let’s make America great. Let’s do that.”

Comments

@Degree-hd8zf

There is a reason they called them NATIVE Americans. Learn history.

@thegeek4576

They’re called native Americans for a reason because they’re natives. You wouldn’t call a white boy a Native American because they aren’t native. Their Ancestors are from Britain.

@no.1spectator39

God bless all Indeginious Native people in the Americas, Lots of support and love from Northeast of India 🇮🇳 (Tribal Brothers)

@DH-oj2ru

"The further away I am from the human race, the better I feel." - Charles Bukowski

@ajaynorris3526

Im not even american and i know that U.S belonged to the natives originally.

@majvi1990

“Go back to Europe” - I totally get you, but we don’t want them either.

@Faus4us

Unity is how we prevail. We are one people 🙏

@thevoicevote7504

How was the man (Nick Sandmann) being offensive? He smiled in the way that the situation was weird. All the others were causing trouble except the Native American drummer.

@fbi4596

I don’t get it when a white person says “go back to your country” like honey whose country do you think you’re in

@user-zu3ll8yk6h

When you are stranger in your own country 😞

@NORMZS8

To all those who feel sad ...what have you ever done except just expressing sadness

@steelersgirl3063

Beautiful the courage he had, and it sure did quite down the crowd. Shows how powerful his voice was and spirit

@tampusclyde6925

"Germany fails to destroy USA" "Russia fails to destroy USA" USA: Fine, I'll do it myself

@sheikhspeare7262

No offence to you United States of America citizens, but there’s something wrong with some of your people. Letting your country down.

@Hasherella

My heart cries for our future. We are all lost in these times. I want to hug everyone.

@manicmechanic24

That teen sued you liberal democrats for millions. Now he's really smiling!😂

@KiyaTheDon

Imagine telling NATIVE Americans this isn’t there land ✋🏾

@shnoops7759

imagine telling a native that their land doesn't belong to them (edit: I see I have summoned a war of SJWs and Racists)

@selfishstockton6123

That old man is a coward for approaching the high school kids and not the black grown ups

@sarahberkner

It's awful how Native Americans were treated but they haven't been here forever either. And it's racist to tell someone "go back to your land" no matter their race.