Man Bought Girlfriend a Phone on His Ex’s Plan?! | Part 1

>> Judge Judy: Why in the world would she be tied to you with a phone bill? She's not with you anymore. You have a new girlfriend, you said. >> Announcer: He's out of her life, but on her cell bill. >> That's the catalyst for her to cut off my service and message between her and my new girlfriend. >> Judge Judy: I would cut off your phone. >> Announcer: And she wants to hang up for good. >> Judge Judy: Did you order a second phone on her account? >> No, I didn't. >> Judge Judy: How many phones d

id he order? >> Nine. >> Announcer: "Judge Judy." >> Judge Judy: Ms. Parsons, the defendant is a former boyfriend of yours. For a period of time, he moved in with you where you were living, and you were living with your parents. >> Correct. >> Judge Judy: During what period of time did he move in with you and your parents? >> I would say we started staying there about September of 2018 until October of 2018. >> Judge Judy: So you're talking about a couple weeks. >> Living at my parents, correct.

>> Judge Judy: Where were you living before September? >> We were just staying together in hotels. He was transferring to my area for a job, and he said that they were paying for hotels until he could find a place to live. >> Judge Judy: When did you start staying together in hotels? >> We started dating in January of 2018, so I'm gonna say sometime in February. >> Judge Judy: And he was working. >> That's what I was told. >> Judge Judy: Correct? >> Yes. >> Judge Judy: And were you working? >>

Yes. >> Judge Judy: Now, Mr. Sparrow, there came a time when Ms. Parson bought you an iPhone. >> Yes. >> Judge Judy: And in what month was that? >> This was in July of 2018. >> Judge Judy: Were you with her when she purchased it? >> I was with her when she purchased the phone. >> Judge Judy: Good. How much did she pay for it? >> She paid the taxes. It was something that was leased, so, like, $47. >> Judge Judy: Now, at some point, Mr. Sparrow, you say that the phone broke. When did it break? >>

In October. >> Judge Judy: Before or after you and the plaintiff broke up? >> In the midst of us breaking up. >> Judge Judy: So, what did you do with the phone? >> I shipped that phone back, and I received another phone. >> Judge Judy: When did you receive the new phone? >> I received the phone, I would like to say, the 16th. After that point, she suspended the service on the 22nd, and on the 23rd, she asked to transfer the line. And it was all based on a message between her and my new girlfrien

d. That's the catalyst for her to cut off my service and -- >> Judge Judy: I would cut off your phone. Why in the world wouldn't she cut off your phone? She's not with you anymore. You have a new girlfriend, you said. Why in the world would she be tied to you with a phone bill? >> But the prior agreement was, I bought a phone for her in May. It was a Galaxy Note8. So, the prior agreement was that I'd get that phone for her, which I got rid of my iPhone X originally so that she would have the pho

ne that she wanted, exactly what she wanted. >> Judge Judy: How much did you pay for it? >> I paid 200 bucks. I traded a phone -- >> Judge Judy: Forget it. Now, she cut off your phone plan. And did you order another phone? >> No, ma'am. >> Judge Judy: So it was just one phone that you got? >> No. >> Yes, ma'am. >> Judge Judy: And I assume you have proof that you sent back the phone? >> I don't have the FedEx paperwork. >> Judge Judy: Okay. So, you have no proof that you sent back the phone. >> C

orrect. >> Judge Judy: Now, is that the only time that you ordered another phone on her account? Or did you order a second phone on her account? >> No, I didn't. >> Judge Judy: So you would agree, if she paid for another phone for you, it would be your responsibility. >> No. >> Judge Judy: Why not? >> On the basis -- >> Judge Judy: Just a second. You already told me that you didn't order another phone. So, why would you have a problem with what I said, that if she can prove that you did order an

other phone after they sent you a replacement, that you would be responsible for that phone? Why would you say no, if you say you didn't order it? If she could prove that you did order another phone, then it would be your responsibility, right? >> No. >> Judge Judy: Okay. How many phones did he order? >> Nine. >> Judge Judy: Can you prove that to me? >> Yes. >> Judge Judy: I'd like to see. >> Three of them were canceled. Two of them were returned. So there were four cellphones that actually hit

my account. Those are the letters from Verizon stating that he sent it and called. >> Judge Judy: Would you show that to him, please? Let me tell you what Verizon said here on October 4th.