Main

Predicting Eclipses: The Three-Body Problem

Nearly 3,000 years ago, ancient Babylonians began one of the longest-running science experiments in history. The goal: to predict eclipses. This singular aim has driven innovation across the history of science and mathematics, from the Saros cycle to Greek geometry to Newton’s calculus to the three-body problem. Today, eclipse prediction is a precise science; NASA scientists predict eclipses hundreds of years into the future. ---------- Read the Quanta article "How the Ancient Art of Eclipse Prediction Became an Exact Science": https://www.quantamagazine.org/how-the-ancient-art-of-eclipse-prediction-became-an-exact-science-20240405/ ---------- Chapters: 00:00 Solving the Three-Body problem is key to predicting eclipses 00:52 Importance of eclipses to ancient civilizations 01:20 The lunar phase cycles, plane of ecliptic, draconic month, anomalistic month 02:18 Discovery of the saros cycle by the Babylonians 03:34 The Antikythera mechanism encodes the saros cycle 04:22 Newton's discoveries lead to new calculations of the eclipse 00:48 How to solve the three-body problem 05:24 NASA's solution to the three-body problem, location of the Earth, moon and sun 06:51 JPL Development Ephemeris 07:25 Predicting future eclipses 08:14 The end of the current saros series ---------- - VISIT our website: https://www.quantamagazine.org - LIKE us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/QuantaNews - FOLLOW us Twitter: https://twitter.com/QuantaMagazine Quanta Magazine is an editorially independent publication supported by the Simons Foundation: https://www.simonsfoundation.org/

Quanta Magazine

2 days ago

This is the first known analog computer. It was designed 2000 years ago to predict an extraordinary cosmic event... when the moon passes in front of the sun causing a total solar eclipse. Eclipses are intimately tied into the history of astronomy and science. It's sort of a triumph of exact science and mathematical science that it's become possible over the course of 3000 years of work to predict when the eclipse will arrive to within a second or two. We can very accurately predict the solar ecl
ipse, when it's going to happen, how it's going to happen for many, many hundreds of years. Eclipse prediction is the giant kind of geometry exercise, but the real thing that had to be solved for eclipses was a Three-Body Problem of the motion of the Earth, moon and sun. What do you actually have to work out to know when the eclipse is going to happen? Eclipses are part of a really larger set of astronomical responsibilities that lots of ancient governments had in regulating time and predicting
astronomical events. For centuries, people were keeping good records about when eclipses happened. The Babylonians, they recorded these astronomical diaries, what planets were where in the sky, where the moon was. It's probably the longest running scientific experiment in history. They started being able to see patterns. Ancient astronomers saw three periodic cycles hidden in the movements of the moon. They noticed it takes 29.5 days to go from one new moon to the next. This full lunar phase cyc
le is known as the synodic month. They also saw that the sun and the moon are confined to two different paths in the sky. That's because of a cosmic quirk. The moon's orbit is tilted at five degrees above the Earth's orbit around the sun, known as the plane of the ecliptic. Every 27.2 days, the draconic month, the moon passes through the plane of the ecliptic at two different nodes. Finally, ancient astronomers observe that the moon appears closer and further away, returning to the same size in
the sky every 27.5 days. This is the anomalistic month caused by the moon's elliptical orbit. Armed with centuries of data, the Babylonians noticed something striking every 6,585 days and eight hours, which is about 18 years. These cycles sync up and this happens. This number came to be known as the saros, a harmonic separating two eclipses. After a saros length of time, the geometry of the sun, Earth, moon system repeats again. The Babylonians realized that in 223 repetitions of the lunar phas
e cycle, you would have 239 repetitions in the apparent size of the moon oscillating and 242 plunges through the plane of the ecliptic. All of these roughly equal the same amount of time. That coincidence is what leads to these saros cycles. Every saros cycle, the postiion of the moon relative to line between the earth and the sun, and relative to the plane of the ecliptic is sort of in the same configuration. That's what produces an eclipse. A few centuries after the discovery of the saros, Gre
ek astronomers combined it with new mathematical models of celestial objects to create the Antikythera mechanism. It's this clockwork computer. It has, I think, 37 gears in it, and as you turn these gears around, it's kind of simulating the motions of planets and the moon and so on, and it encodes the saros cycle and it has a very coarse approximation to predicting eclipses. But there are limitations. The saros can predict roughly when an eclipse will occur, not where it will be visible on Earth
. For the next 2000 years, the quest for a precise method of eclipse prediction would drive scientific innovation across the world. You go from the earliest days of science to geometricization of astronomy and then the calculusization of astronomy in the hands of Newton. But then the race was on to figure out, given Newton's law's of motion, law of gravitation, it's like, well, then we should be able to figure out exactly where the moon is and exactly when eclipses are going to occur. People wer
e impressed Newton had solved the two-body problem. It's like, how hard can it now be to solve the three-body problem? Well, it turned out to be really hard. We've got these differential equations that represent the motion of Earth, moon, and sun. according to Newton's laws. A differential equation says that the rate of change of one thing is determined by some other thing. When people say solve the three-body problem, they typically mean find a formula for where each of those bodies will be. Th
at formula we can't find, but we can perfectly well work out the numerical value for the positions of these bodies. In the 1960s, NASA started directly computing numerical approximations to the three-body problem. But to solve these differential equations, you first need to know the Earth, sun, and moon's initial conditions or the positions and velocities at some particular time. Roger tower. Now we know where the moon is because there are reflective mirrors on it that the Apollo astronauts put.
There are five reflectors on the moon. We send the laser pulse to it, it bounces back and returns to the Earth. And from that information, we can figure out the distance information between the Earth and the moon. And we can usually process this data to about centimeter scale. So the moon's position and its future position are better understood than almost anywhere else we would want to go or think about. To find the Earth's position relative to the sun, NASA uses data from the Deep Space Netwo
rk, an array of spacecraft missions across the solar system. The part that most occupied the ancients, where will the celestial bodies be is effectively solved and it's solved because NASA has missions all over the solar system and they're taking data from all of these missions, and then they're crunching it through a very complicated model. This mathematical model is called the JPL Development Ephemeris. It's stores, the positions and velocities of the sun, Earth, moon, and other gravitational
variables as a sequence of Chebyshev polynomial coefficients. A special kind of function that is convenient for finding new data points based on existing data points. So you have bunch of points and try to figure out, okay, which curve gives us the minimum difference between the observation and the fitted line. So of course, what we are doing is slightly more complicated, but the essence of how we do things is just the curve fitting. Think of the Antikythera device with that 37 cogs, well now we
've got 20,000 cogs that we happen to be implementing electronically to compute when eclipses will occur. To predict the next eclipse, and ones thousands of years into the future, NASA uses the JPL Ephemeris to find out when the sun, Earth, and moon will line up. Then using a handful of numbers called Besselian elements, scientists can predict when and where the moon shadow will intersect with the Earth's surface. One of the things that's kind of nice about eclipses is that they are the pinnacle
of kind of, achievement for something you can really predict with great precision on the basis of traditional mathematical science. We no longer rely on the saros to predict eclipses, but it remains a powerful tool for approximating them. The saros series will be hundreds of eclipses. At any given time, there are multiple saros series active. The North American Total Solar Eclipse of 2024 is part of the Saros Series 139, which started in 1501. And eventually what happens is that the cone of sha
dow of the moon will miss the Earth. And then that's the end of that saros series. Saros 139 will end in 2750, beginning another chapter in the story of human innovation.

Comments