Main

The real reason Egypt is moving its capital

Cairo isn’t the problem. Subscribe and turn on notifications 🔔 so you don't miss any videos: http://goo.gl/0bsAjO In 2017, Egypt’s government announced it would build a new capital city 45 kilometers outside of Cairo, the current capital. It was a shocking announcement since Cairo, a city of more than 10,000,000 people, has been the capital of Egypt for decades. The government claims that Cairo has become too overcrowded and that moving the capital will give both Cairo’s residents and government workers more space. But this excuse is not new. For decades, Egypt’s rulers have been building brand new cities in the desert. None of them have solved Cairo’s density issue. And based on how construction is going, this new capital won’t be a solution either. So why does Egypt want a new capital? Well, it has a lot to do with the political revolution in 2011. Watch this episode of Vox Atlas to understand the real reason behind Egypt’s giant new capital city. Sources: Mohamed Elshahed’s extensive expertise on architectural history and urbanism helped us understand why creating new cities and communities doesn’t actually improve livelihoods in Cairo: Nasr City was once Egypt’s new capital, but things went wrong: https://cairobserver.com/post/114391196879/nasr-city-was-once-egypts-new-capital-but-things#.YxdfIezMLUY Revolutionary Modernism? Architecture and the Politics of Transition in Egypt 1936-1967: https://www.proquest.com/openview/e199f143de3d7dc0a53ea314215fb58a/1?pq-origsite=gscholar&cbl=18750&diss=y For historical maps of Cairo, we mainly relied on these three books: Understanding Cairo: The Logic of a City Out of Control by David Sims https://books.google.com/books/about/Understanding_Cairo.html?id=_9gKRQAACAAJ Egypt’s Desert Dreams: Development or Disaster by David Sims https://books.google.com/books/about/Egypt_s_Desert_Dreams.html?id=QauFoAEACAAJ Cairo by André Raymond https://www.hup.harvard.edu/catalog.php?isbn=9780674009967 We used this report by LSE cities to compare densities between major cities at 1:52: https://lsecities.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/Final-Developing-Urban-Futures-Urban-Age-conference-newspaper.pdf For the map at 5:05, we used an updated informal cities map created by Ahmed Zaazaa, a researcher and urban designer. For the demolitions and displacement locations, we used press clippings from Egypt Today and maps from the Cairo 2050 plan. Not all locations are shown. https://www.egypttoday.com/Article/Search?title=slums https://cairofrombelow.files.wordpress.com/2011/08/cairo-2050-vision-v-2009-gopp-12-mb.pdf These three links helped us create the diagram at 6:42 that shows the population target gaps in Greater Cairo’s new cities: The Built Environment Observatory: http://marsadomran.info/en/facts_budgets/2016/11/485/ City Population: https://www.citypopulation.de/en/egypt/cities/ Egypt census data: https://egypt.opendataforafrica.org/tadpaqg These two pieces helped guide the direction of our video: The Sinister Side of Sisi’s Urban Development by Maged Mandour https://carnegieendowment.org/sada/84504 Why is Egypt building a new capital by Mustafa Menshaway https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2021/7/5/why-is-egypt-building-a-new-capital And a special thanks to the many others based in Cairo who helped us research for this video. Unfortunately, their names could not be listed due to safety concerns. Make sure you never miss behind-the-scenes content in the Vox Video newsletter, sign up here: http://vox.com/video-newsletter Vox.com is a news website that helps you cut through the noise and understand what's really driving the events in the headlines. Check out http://www.vox.com Support Vox's reporting with a one-time or recurring contribution: http://vox.com/contribute-now Shop the Vox merch store: http://vox.com/store Watch our full video catalog: http://goo.gl/IZONyE Follow Vox on Facebook: http://facebook.com/vox Follow Vox on Twitter: http://twitter.com/voxdotcom Follow Vox on TikTok: http://tiktok.com/@voxdotcom

Vox

1 year ago

This is Cairo. Egypt’s largest city and its capital. For decades it's been home to Egyptian rulers and their palaces. The Parliament has met in this building for over 150 years. And this public square in the heart of Cairo has been the site of several revolutions. But in 2015, the Egyptian government announced the capital would move about 50 kilometers away... To this patch of empty desert. Which is quickly shaping up to be the New Administrative Capital of Egypt. This is where a new presidentia
l palace will go... the new Parliament building and a new public square. Egypt’s government, led by president Abdel Fattah El-Sisi claims this new city will solve a specific problem: Cairo’s overpopulation. But the country has a long history of building new cities to decongest Cairo. Many of them sit outside the city today. So, why is Cairo’s population still considered a ticking time bomb? And what’s the real reason behind this new capital? There's a population counter outside one of the min
istries. It's mundane, but it also it's red, flashing lights with these colors is almost always like telling people... A little too many of you are here. This is Mohamed Elshahed an architectural historian who studies urban development in Egypt. And I find this to be quite a dangerous narrative especially since that's actually not the case. Egypt's home to more than 100 million people. And about 20% of them live within the boundaries of Greater Cairo. The city has one of the highest population
densities in the world with 153,000 people per square kilometer at its peak. That’s higher than New York, London, and Shanghai. What we know as Cairo, today, was officially founded on the banks of the Nile in the 10th century, as the capital of the Arab Fatimid Caliphate. The city had to be built near the river because the rest of the region was barren desert. Over the next several centuries, each ruler built expansions of Cairo close to the fertile banks. The Ottomans built these areas... and
the British added these suburbs during their decades-long occupation of Egypt. In the 1950s, when the British left and Egypt became a republic Cairo was by far the biggest city. In the 50s, 60s and 70s, millions of impoverished Egyptians from the countryside moved to Cairo in search of opportunities and better living conditions. But the city that was built haphazardly along the river wasn't equipped to house more people. The city sort of was already kind of shaped and demarcated and the green ar
eas around it were left agricultural. And it's those areas that were cheap and close enough to those amenities that allowed then people to step in. Since the housing that was available was completely not sufficient. So farmers started selling small slices of their agricultural land to the migrants. A lot of people have to build for themselves with little money. So together, so entire families would go vertical on a small plot of land. These were the first informal and technically illegal neighb
orhoods. It's informal because it's not, you know, given licenses for construction. It's built outside of the economy, that is the “official economy". And I think this is actually the result of the fact that the economic system really excluded the majority of the population. For decades, Egypt's government failed to build affordable housing or invest in public services and infrastructure to support the explosive growth in Cairo’s density. And that meant these unplanned and informal neighborhood
s continued to get more and more crowded until it became a crisis. "Egypt’s capital is bursting at the seams." "Cairo is equipped to handle around 3 million, in fact, it's home to 8 million." "Housing is an area of desperate need." "Many people in Cairo live in makeshift shacks in the city's center and in much worse conditions in the suburbs." Today, these informal neighborhoods are home to 60% of Cairo’s population. Most of them are inhabited by the poor but many have evolved into middle class
neighborhoods. Collectively, these are the most crowded areas of Cairo. And Egypt’s government, under Sisi, points to them as the real problem behind Cairo's overcrowding. I find this to be a very problematic narrative because then we take a question of let's say, bad design or bad management from a state perspective and turn the blame on actually the people who are suffering from the bad design and the bad policies and say, there's just too many of you. In fact, the government still considers t
hem illegal, referring to them as slums. From the point of view of the state, calling an area a slum facilitates its removal. In 2019, the government announced it would eradicate Cairo's slums by 2030. Many neighborhoods will be redeveloped as affluent housing while thousands of residents will be forcibly pushed out of their homes and into affordable housing outside the city. But instead of focusing on sufficient affordable housing they invested billions of dollars in a whole new city elsewhere.
And it's not the first time an Egyptian ruler has tried to solve the crisis by starting fresh in the desert. "A building boom is in progress." "New apartment blocks are going up at a greater rate since the start of Nasser’s Revolution." The concept of a new city as a solution for Cairo's growing population began in the 1950s. The first attempt was under President Gamal Abdel Nasser who ordered the construction of a new city called Nasr City. It was also designed to be a new capital at the tim
e. There would be space for government buildings, markets, and a huge new stadium. But there was a big flaw. The plan didn't involve affordable housing for the people in Cairo's most crowded areas. The need was for a lot of lower class housing. But that wasn't going to be placed in the new capital. Nobody wants to build a shiny new capital and then fill it with low cost housing. So it's sort of a trend that already starts there. By the 1970s, Egypt had a new leader, Anwar Sadat who didn’t end
up moving the capitol to Nasr City. But he really leaned into the trend of building ‘desert cities’. Starting in 1976, Egypt’s government built 8 new cities in the desert around Cairo. Each time they claimed the goal was to alleviate overcrowding. But, most included only expensive housing. And barely any featured public transportation making them inaccessible for anyone without a car. That’s why today, many of these desert cities are only partially occupied. Most who have moved here are Cairo’s
middle and upper class residents. That means that the majority of the population that's squeezed in the little green belt that's now urbanized around the Nile are kind of X’d-out of these developments. So we're looking at a condition that's a result of I would say, 3 to 4 decades in particular of misguided policy that looks to the outside of the city. President Sisi is continuing that trend with his new capital. These areas are designated for housing, but mostly for middle and upper class res
idents. Those people are not moving in with handouts. They're buying their those properties. And so the main target audience is, again, a moneyed class. I think the housing for low-income communities will be included in the capital but definitely very limited. All of this land will be used for government buildings and this section will be a business district featuring this soon-to-be-tallest building in Africa. So, if this new capital isn’t really about solving Cairo’s population density crisi
s why is the government so determined to build it? In 2011, protests erupted in Egypt over police brutality. And they quickly evolved into widespread calls for the resignation of Egypt’s ruler of 30 years, Hosni Mubarak. Demonstrations took place all over Egypt. But the biggest were in Cairo. Specifically, Tahrir Square. It’s been the epicenter of many political demonstrations since the early 20th century. Largely because it’s so close to Egyptian government buildings, including the Parliament
. In 2011, millions of people occupied Tahrir Square for 18 days. They set up roadblocks... and battled with police. On February 11, thousands marched from Tahrir Square to the presidential palace, 10 km away where they ultimately forced Mubarak to step down. The ability to control Tahrir Square and inner Cairo allowed the protestors to effectively paralyze the government. Making their presence and their demands impossible to ignore. Sisi remembers that. He was the head of Egypt’s powerful m
ilitary when he seized power in 2013 on the heels of the revolution. Barely a month after taking power he commanded his soldiers and police to crack down on protestors who opposed him. The brutal raid killed more than 800 people. Ever since, he's been systematically trying to prevent a revolution that could topple him. His government has shut down political dissents, punished journalists, and hindered free speech. Now, they are redesigning several aspects of Cairo to make the city harder to pro
test in. They’ve widened dozens of streets making it more difficult to erect road-blocks. And they plan to add 40 bridges which will give the military and police easier access to the city center. Sisi’s government has also renovated Tahrir Square adding giant monuments and private security guards which, some experts, say will make it harder for large crowds to gather. Now, they’re taking the final step: removing the government entirely from Cairo. Just 7 years after announcing the construction
of the new capital government officials are starting to move into these new buildings. Once that’s complete, all of Egypt’s political power, including Sisi will be concentrated here... almost 50 kilometers from Cairo. And it will all be under heavy guard: this is the military's sprawling complex nearby. Even though there is a public square, called the People’s Piazza it’s hard to imagine millions of people making the journey from Cairo to demonstrate here. And that may be the point. The dist
ance, plus the military presence will allow Sisi to defend his power in case of an uprising. So instead of a capital that offers a solution for the people of Cairo this city is designed to move the government out of their reach.

Comments

@Vox

This is an episode of Vox Atlas, where we demonstrate where conflicts occurs on a map and the ways in which foreign policy shapes a region. Watch more episodes of Atlas here: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLJ8cMiYb3G5e4MOmzf-piIWQb4INRW18g

@hugonordin

How considerate of them to include a new revolution square.

@Fusilier7

So basically, Egypt's new capital is the new Versailles, which was more than just the palace, it was the administrative capital of the Kingdom of France. The king was then followed by other aristocrats, who built their mansions away from Paris, some around Versailles, while others were in more remote locations, effectively abandoning the poor to squalour and neglect in Paris. Although the nobility could forget the poor, the poor never forgot the nobility, so when the revolution occurred, they marched all the way to Versailles, and laid siege to the estate, forcing the royals to surrender. If history is a guild, Egypt's new capital will not make long outstanding problems go away, there is no distance far enough for the oligarchy to escape revolutionaries, justice is patient.

@pliska6819

I remember visiting Egypt with my family in the late 90s and remember that the economic situation of the country was pretty good. They had a quite strong pound (circa $1 = 3 EGP) and pretty calm atmosphere and remember the people were not that commercialised. The last time we went in 2018, we were pretty shocked how things have drastically changed. It became so overcrowded, polluted and chaotic. According to some random locals we spoke with, the current government is literally working against its own population and not to mention the opression and suffocation caused on a daily basis especially by the police. Also why change Cairo, which is a city so full of history and character to a souless, artificial capital where all the elite will live? This will create nothing but social segregation and tensions, in my humble opinion. Of course, the choice is entirely theirs. It's a pity how such a beautiful country with very rich history is being destroyed by the mafia politicians (similar to many Balkan countries for example).

@rodrigodurco

in Brasil we had a similar experience; they made Brasília a city with extremely wide streets and squares to make it harder (but not impossible, as we recently saw) to gather protesters; while in Rio, the old capital, the narrow streets surrounding Catete palace would be easily filled with people. it’s all about moving the power away from us.

@terramater

There's another unknown ticking time-bomb in Cairo: water - or the lack thereof. We've spent a lot of time researching the Nile droughts, Middle Eastern water scarcity and solutions for it, while working on our Nile and desalination videos, and... it doesn't look good: artificial upscale urban developments in the desert mean diverting huge amounts of water away from the city where it is badly needed.

@janeteholmes

The creation of Versailles, 12 miles from Paris, was one of the factors leading to the French Revolution. It isolated the king from the people so he had no idea what was really happening in Paris. Ignoring the peasants is risky.

@Master-X-D

As an Egyptian I want to thank you for highlighting this

@sararefaat2465

Very accurate analysis of what’s currently happening in Egypt…very unfortunate but very true! Thank you for sharing and raising awareness!

@expandedhistory

One of the worries for me in this plan is that they are bound to create another traffic nightmare: The seperation of residential areas from commercial areas. If you give people the opportunity to walk to work or walk to the shops, they will do it. That has been proven over and over again. But if you force people to drive by only offering flats/houses far away from their place of work, traffic will become a problem eventually. You can somewhat counteract that problem with good public transport, but even the best public transport will not fix bad city design.

@LouieGrind

One of the rare cities where it's more affordable to live in the center of the city than outside. Extremely fascinating!

@mohammednasser2159

Several times in the past couple of years, there were protest attempts but it was easily shut down by the law enforcement. Tahrir Square now is crowded by police officers wearing civilian clothing and asking pedestrians about where are they going. And even search their phones and check social media for anti-government posts. Happened to me and alot of my friends. It's really inhumane.

@kenosabi

You know the Iranian shah, French royalty, etc ... also lived in isolated palaces. It had the opposite effect that Sisi is looking for -- it angered the people even more. It acted as greater motivation and didn't deter the revolution, it fueled it. It made it easier for the serfs to look around and realize just how out of touch and how different royalties life is compared to the people.

@douglasfariaxp

It was one of the reasons that they built Brasilia city as a new capital in Brazil. Brasilia was designed for driving, not for walking.

@deeluve22

"The real reason Egypt is moving its capital" Me: This is not just about making it harder for people to protest the government, is it? **Watches video** Me: Oh...it is.

@mennaragaie00

The video perfectly illustrated the situation in Egypt right now however in real life, it even more worse than what have been illustrated in the video. He destroyed all the well known places In Cairo like zamalek area. He eliminated the middle class. You either have to be very rich to be able to access those areas like zayed or new cairo. Or very poor with zero facility and with no affordability to buy even a bread and ofc you can access only the poor areas which are all cairo basically except of zayed, new captial, new cairo..etc. I went back home after 5 years, he eliminated the middle class. Middle class people can’t even keep up with the inflation happening there. We can’t talk, we can’t protest and we can’t do anything. Which don’t give us any option other than leaving the country. Today 90% of the educated middle class people outside Egypt. The rest who are under poverty line are there as they don’t have any other option. He literally destroyed Egypt and above all, all our country’s projects right now are under only 2 countries. You better guess it correctly :)

@dolphin550

Egypt's new captial situation reminds me of the situation in Myanmar. As both rulers of the countries prioritize keeping a distance between their government and the people, so that the government could govern and not be toppled.

@ks_ig2728

To quote a certain YouTuber: “Bigly big buildings in this new bigly big city”

@johanburet5041

That was one of the main point of the palace of Versailles, being a bit removed from Paris. In the end, it prevented nothing.

@spacethreads

I remember leaving Egypt as a kid with my mom and 2 siblings at the end of January 2011. this was around the time of the revolution. it was a scary day that I still remember. my mom was really scared we'll get caught. the place was really crowded. I remember Cairo's airport was packed and people were trying to leave the country. I was fortunate enough to leave the country but many many people aren't. most of my family still reside in Egypt and it's not pretty there. Cairo is my home city. I was born there and I lived there until I turned about 5 years old, that's when we left. the economic situation in Egypt is really really bad and it's sad seeing that all the efforts towards the new capital is just to shut people up