Main

Watch a Risky China-Philippines Confrontation in the South China Sea | WSJ

China’s maritime militia surrounded a Philippine convoy on a resupply mission in the disputed South China Sea. It would become one of the most significant confrontations between the two countries in recent years. WSJ’s Feliz Solomon explains why these resupply missions are becoming increasingly dangerous as she witnessed the hourslong standoff on board a Philippine coast guard ship called the BRP Cabra. Chapters: 0:00 South China Sea 0:25 On board the ship 1:28 Chinese helicopter 2:07 The Chinese fleet 3:21 Sierra Madre resupplied #China #Philippines #WSJ

The Wall Street Journal

2 weeks ago

We're aboard a ship on a mission deep into the heart of the South China Sea. It's a days long journey through some of the most contested waters in the world. You can see how close the Chinese Coast Guard is getting to our vessel. It looks like it's really about to hit us and it will end in one of the most significant confrontations between China and the Philippines in recent years. For the first time, foreign journalists have been invited to join a resupply mission traveling over 100 nautical mi
les to a remote military outpost. That's at the center of a fierce dispute between China and the Philippines. We're on board the BRP Cobra, one of two Coast Guard ships traveling from Palawan Island to meet two small supply boats. The Coast Guard's plan is to escort the supply vessels from Sabina Shoal to Second Thomas Shoal. The journey is taking us through China's nine dash line marking Beijing's expansive claims to the sea. Our destination is a reef. Both China and the Philippines claim as th
eir own. Manila deliberately grounded the Sierra Madre. A World War Two airship here in 1999 to stake its claim to the area. A permanent contingent of Filipino Marines is stationed on the rusting dilapidated wreckage missions to resupply the Sierra Madre have grown increasingly dangerous as China attempts to prevent the resupply boats from reaching their destination. Just hours into our voyage. It's clear our convoy has been spotted. There's a helicopter flying overhead, it went past us a few mi
nutes ago towards the other Philippine coast guard boat then turned around. This is a Chinese Navy helicopter. It's the first sign we've seen so far that the Chinese are aware that we're here under the cover of darkness. We arrive at Sabina Shoal, the rendezvous point. We've just met up with the supply boats. There's one just behind me and another one over there and now we're making our way towards Second Thomas Shoal. In the dead of night, the Chinese Coast Guard starts to shadow our fleet by d
awn. We're surrounded. The Chinese vessels are on, they're getting really close to us. This is Chinese Coast Guard vessel 3305. The Chinese fleet begins to encircle our ship preventing us from getting close to the supply boat. Our boat is sort of turning away now because you can see how close the Chinese Coast Guard is getting to our a short distance away. The crew aboard the other Philippine Coast Guard vessels scramble as a Chinese ship collides into its bow. The Chinese fleet takes positions
around our convoy veering close to block the entrance to the reef fleets of fishing vessels controlled by the Chinese coast Guard move into place. This is China's Maritime Militia in action. We're now completely surrounded by Chinese vessels. Some of them are Chinese Coast Guard and some of them are Chinese flag fishing vessels that appear to be part of its maritime Militia. One of the Filipino supply boats has become separated from its protection as it tries to break through the Chinese fleet.
The small boat is surrounded and blasted with water cannons from two Chinese coast guard ships. The cannons smash into the bridge, shattering windows and injuring those inside, forcing the boat to turn back. Finally, the remaining supply boat manages to break through the Chinese line, sailing through the blocking ships to deliver its crucial supplies to the marines aboard Sierra Madre. Hours after the standoff began, China's coast guard would later say that its actions were to curtail what it ca
lled. The Philippine vessel's intrusion into the waters around the reef and that it allowed the supply vessel to pass as our convoy makes its way back to the island of Palawan. We are constantly shadowed by a Chinese vessel as encounters in the sea grow more aggressive. So too do the risks of these confrontations spilling over into something much more dangerous.

Comments

@piperdude82

I’m no military man, but that looked a little too close to an armed confrontation for my liking.

@marcwells03

Time for Philippines to build up their navy with bigger ships

@josephkendall9793

Wow that is very scary. Much respect the Filipinos for maintaining their ground. Takes a lot of courage.

@efone3553

The arrogance of the Chinese is mind boggling. For them to think that the entire sea is theirs only is just unbelievable.

@downpourmaker8058

still no country recognizing the 10 dash lines...

@Asiankid0508

This is not confrontation but a bullying.

@christianjohncid1072

David ang Goliath, Filipinos are so Brave god bless all filipino.

@user-xt1jr8do8x

The 1982 United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, to which China is a signatory, mandates states to respect Exclusive Economic Zones (EEZs) as a legal basis. An EEZ is an area extending 200 nautical miles from a country's coastline, within which the country has special rights regarding the exploration and use of marine resources. However, China seeks to extend its territory well beyond its EEZ, disregarding the territorial claims of Southeast Asian countries. Despite an arbitration court ruling that declared China's actions lacked a legal basis. Unlike most nations that settle territorial dispute this way, in a respectful and peaceful manner, China refuses to honor the court decision. They even threaten war. This behavior demonstrates China's greediness in pursuing expansive territorial claims, undermining international agreements, and the sovereignty of neighboring nations. China disregards its own agreement and international laws which it willingly entered into. At this point, how can you trust China? Beware, just another Putin!

@dwrzd

thats west philippines sea not south china sea

@ExcessiveDrip

This is next level pettiness

@jarrettbobbett5230

Im waiting for the Philippines to defend their territory.

@brxrmr

0:07 you can easily see who's the one doing the bullying here. one does not care a collision will occur while the other side is preventing it.

@HenriHattar

They should NOT HAVE to stake their claim, it is clearly in Philippine exclusive economic zone!

@lastChang

This should invoke the 🇺🇸 US - Philippines's 🇵🇭 Mutual Defense agreement.

@ca3jcoef

Bullying a smaller country is cowardness.

@lawrencefrost9063

You can lose your eye sight or go deaf if that water hits you. It hits you like a truck and your ears and eyes are VERY vulnerable, just FYI. This could have gone bad. It's very common actually (since water cannons are used in crowd control, there are plenty of examples)

@avillageofbigheads

If all of us took a count of " Made in China" products at home, on average, it could easily amount to more than 50%. Then we wonder, how come China has so much power.

@samtingwong8627

I have a high respect Chinese before. Now no more.

@Green_spanner

Thank you WSJ for showing this to the world.

@ArabicReja973

The international law is very clear on the South China Sea: - parts of it belong to some ASEAN countries including the Philippines 🇵🇭, - the rest of it is the international water, - no part of it belongs to China🇨🇳 or Taiwan🇹🇼.